Dream Theater

A Dramatic Turn Of Events Thread
September 12, 2011 2:21:34 AM UTC Post #51

I'll ignore for now the poster above the last one, as he's obviously so 'prog' that he's writing stuff about what I havent written.

But the points about SFaM, SDoIT, ToF et all don't ring true at all - I loved all of those on the first listen, as I did with every one of the previous albums.

ADTOE is just very hard going as its not at all fluid and many parts of it just seem contrived to be there as 'fill-ins'.

September 12, 2011 2:52:46 AM UTC Post #52

Oh and one more thing for now - I've read in a lot of places that this is DT going 'back to their roots'.

This is a total cop out - you ALWAYS have your roots - you just build, grow and improve on them.

So instead of 'going back to their roots', it should read - 'slipping backwards and sounding old'.

September 12, 2011 3:25:53 AM UTC Post #53

@SteveRaven, I've found ADTOE to have actually the opposite effect on me. This album is a grower. Every time I listen to it (about 10 times now) I like it even more and hear and appreciate just how great it really is. This, to me anyway, is the key to longevity. This is complex and melodic progressive metal and each member is at the top of his game. Don't give up so fast. Keep spinning it and I'm pretty sure it will grow on you too.

I've done all I can

September 12, 2011 12:19:44 PM UTC Post #54

Still waiting for the album to be released here in our lovely country Turkey,i am so excited about it after reading these comments about the new album here...

www.egemay.com
September 12, 2011 12:40:21 PM UTC Post #55

Been holding out on watching the DVD until the kids were back at school ,so I could watch in peace,so glad I did ,just loved watching MM s face when he got the phone call ,priceless ,hope hes as good live as he looked and sounded on the DVD
Steve.

September 12, 2011 12:53:58 PM UTC Post #56

=aneksteve said:...hope hes as good live as he looked and sounded on the DVD
Steve.

He is! Mangini is really great live, I can assure you).

September 12, 2011 8:04:30 PM UTC Post #57

I really love ADTOE......I had a similar feeling when I heard SFAM for the first time. Great riffs, great vocals one after another.
In prog music you have to hear the CD SEVERAL times to really appreciate every aspect.... same here....
Mangini's drumming is different, but should be this way... there is no point in having a World Class Drummer trying to emulate another drummer. But he is a genius and fits perfectly fine.
Looking forward to seeing them live!

September 12, 2011 8:39:17 PM UTC Post #58

Thoroughly satisfied & impressed !

September 13, 2011 4:49:08 AM UTC Post #59

Initial listens finally in. Miles better than BCSL imo.

A classic DT album. Not a radio-worthy track on the disc. Hell yeah.

James back in the stratosphere. No more faux Opeth screamsing. This album delivers pure DT.

September 13, 2011 8:53:43 PM UTC Post #60

I’m sure I missed this somewhere, but can anyone tell me how the clown on the cover artwork fits into the album?

Post your comment

You must be logged in to comment

Please sign up for an account or current members login.